Yu-Gi-Oh! ยป Custom Cards

Customs Feedback
PristinePersephone
#1
Hi! I'm new to making Custom Cards but I just made my First Complete Archetype and I'd really appreciate a second glance on the PSCT and overall balance of them
https://www.duelingbook.com/deck?id=21224477
(Artwork is from the var. Rush Duel Cards, most of which belong to the Rush Duel "Celeb Rose" archetype)
Resonance360
#2
Looks strong but I do have some critiques, I'll give some on PSCT and then balancing, of course take em however you like:

- In Mage's text, it asks for you to search a 'Celeb Rose' S/T specifically when there aren't any targets for that

- If a card is paying a cost for an effect after its use case is met (requirement): it should use a semi colon to indicate it (cost); and then the effect would apply

Balancing wise:

- Aside from warlock a lot of the cards seem to require you to have another card like it in hand to play, while it sounds fun at first and not all decks need to run one card super-combos it can make clunky hands, look at decks like VW for examples of this lol

- The deck seems to run way to many cards that also don't start your combos or lead anywhere on their own. A good deck should aim to minimize the bad cards it plays to simple engine requirements. Also certain effects seem unnecessary - On Death Wild you have an effect that says you can treat the equipped monster as 'Witch' even though no other card requires that - additional attack points here an there are nice, too, but given your boss monster are already pretty massive anyways, I don't think it's needed.

- Last thing is the amount of negates oh my god. I think if you payed this deck out right, 2 cards could technically lead into 6 non OPT negates. (Fab Magician and Main Deck Magician) Also all the other effects read crazy too lmao.

I don't think this is deck that would get realistically printed at this point but if you balanced it out and tweaked it I think you've got a dinger of an archetype for custom games. Just introduce your witches to hard once per turns in some cases.

Resonance360

PristinePersephone
#3
Thank you for the Reply! To address your critiques

- Yeaaaah, making these cards (especially the fusions) I didn't consider that 2 card combo's are a lot less common nowadays, and it does make it feel clunky (which isn't a good thing and does not "balance the possibly absurd effects" as I hoped it would...)

- I took like 23 Artworks and just decided I'd make them all cards with no for sight, Which is...not a good way to do things I am learning.

- Main Deck Witch originally just had a "pop a 'Celeb' equip spell from your field or in hand' Effect, which I thiiink i changed because I wanted it to work better with Fab. Magician? Which, in hindsight, doubled the Omni-Negates the deck has access too, My bad. Other effect Craziness is due to my lack of game knowledge, which is a larger problem then I thought.

Thank you for your feedback and I DEFINITELY FORGOT HARD ONCE PER TURNS OH GOODNESS!!! I THOUGHT THEY WERE THERE. I am understanding the importance of planning things ahead of time, and will possibly fix these cards in the future, or at the very least remember these things for next time. Thank you again :D
Post Reply: