Duelingbook Forum

Cromat wrote:Question #32:
Opponent controls a face-up "Cyber Dragon Herz", then activate "Machine Duplication" by targeting "Cyber Dragon Herz". I activated to that Spell's activation the "Bad Aim" by targeting "Cyber Dragon Herz". Can opponent still Summon of their "Cyber Dragon" monsters?

Cromat wrote:Question #33:

[1] Opponent Summons of "Salamangreat Heatleo" during their Main Phase 1. And you give response to that by activating your Set "Demise of the Land".
● Because of priority that is opponent's turn therefore "Salamangreat Heatleo" will resolve first then they can shuffle 1 card from your Spell & Trap Zone into your Deck then your Quick-Play Spell resolves and you can place your "Mystic Mine".
● When "Salamangreat Heatleo" Summoned: Because of the priorty, they can target 1 card from your Spell & Trap Zone; then your "Mystic Mine" arrives to field, and they can shuffle of your "Mystic Mine" into your Deck back.

[2] Opponent Summons of "Tri-Brigade Shuraig the Ominous Omen" during their Main Phase 1. And you give response of that by activating your Set "Demise of the Land".
● Opponent's turn it is so, they can banish 1 card on the field. For example if they pointed your Set "Demise of the Land" for meaning banish it. And if you activated that Quick-Play Spell to response of that Link Monster's Summon: Your Quick-Play Spell is banished and your "Mystic Mine" arrive to field successfully.
● Chain Links resolve backwards, so your "Mystic Mine" will arrives to field, then your opponent banish it.

According to [1] and [2]; what happens (which one starting with [●]) as correctly, explain please. If there is something as wrong to event(s), explain it too. Then fix it by explaining correct one.

Cromat wrote:Question #34:

For "Sky Striker Maneuver - Vector Blast"; when I activated that.. For shuffle into Deck of my opponent's monsters from Extra Monster Zone, must be in my GY 3 or more Spell that when I activated, or, when I send 2 cards from top of my Deck to GY, after that, now there are 3 or more Spell became at my GY; for I can shuffle cards from my opponent's Extra Monster Zone's to their Deck?

(I hope I succeeded to make you understand the question that I asked.)

Cromat wrote:Question #35:

I had drawn a card from my Main Deck by misunderstanding "Extra Net"; when opponent made a Special Summon from their Main Deck, opponent warned me, so I placed it to top of my Deck back. Should I shuffle my Deck or I have to show that illegal drawn card to my opponent? What should be done? (The opponent told me "You have to show that card to me because that is Ruling." But I know as that illegal drawn card(s) must place to top of Deck in same order and Deck shouldn't shuffle. Or do you prefer to give a warning me?)

Giving false information about information that is considered Private Knowledge, or intentionally revealing information that is considered Private Knowledge, may result in a Disqualification penalty.

Cromat wrote:Question #35:

I had drawn a card from my Main Deck by misunderstanding "Extra Net"; when opponent made a Special Summon from their Main Deck, opponent warned me, so I placed it to top of my Deck back. Should I shuffle my Deck or I have to show that illegal drawn card to my opponent? What should be done? (The opponent told me "You have to show that card to me because that is Ruling." But I know as that illegal drawn card(s) must place to top of Deck in same order and Deck shouldn't shuffle. Or do you prefer to give a warning me?)

Lil Oldman wrote:

Cromat wrote:Question #35:

I had drawn a card from my Main Deck by misunderstanding "Extra Net"; when opponent made a Special Summon from their Main Deck, opponent warned me, so I placed it to top of my Deck back. Should I shuffle my Deck or I have to show that illegal drawn card to my opponent? What should be done? (The opponent told me "You have to show that card to me because that is Ruling." But I know as that illegal drawn card(s) must place to top of Deck in same order and Deck shouldn't shuffle. Or do you prefer to give a warning me?)

Well, you do make an irreparable game state through this. I remember someone telling that was the reason Time Seal got banned at some point. For allowing Rule Sharking. I guess I would show and place the card on top, but according to Konami's Policy, and I quote

Giving false information about information that is considered Private Knowledge, or intentionally revealing information that is considered Private Knowledge, may result in a Disqualification penalty.

Which includes the Deck, so in theory, while in organized play, like rated, you could get a penalty from that.

Cromat wrote:Question #36:

* Opponent's "Sea Stealth Attack" banished "Adamancipator Risen - Dragite" until the End Phase. My opponent argues as Cromat's "Mystic Mine" destroys during End Phase first, and then, I can return of my Synchro monster to the field back while there is no around that Field Spell anymore.
* I argues as that Trap banishes the monster until End Phase, therefore during End Phase, my opponent still has a monster, so my Field Spell will not be destroyed.

- What will happen? (Explain the situation accurately.)

greg503 wrote:

Cromat wrote:Question #36:

* Opponent's "Sea Stealth Attack" banished "Adamancipator Risen - Dragite" until the End Phase. My opponent argues as Cromat's "Mystic Mine" destroys during End Phase first, and then, I can return of my Synchro monster to the field back while there is no around that Field Spell anymore.
* I argues as that Trap banishes the monster until End Phase, therefore during End Phase, my opponent still has a monster, so my Field Spell will not be destroyed.

- What will happen? (Explain the situation accurately.)

https://www.yugioh-card.com/en/play/fast-effect-timing/
The turn player would have priority to activate an effect, but this also means they have to resolve mandatory effects first (the non-turn player doesn't get priority until an effect(s) that start a chain are activated, or all mandatory things are resolved). If you have the Mine and it is your turn, Mine activates before Sea Stealth Attack returns the Dragite, if you have the Mine and it is not your turn, they should resolve Sea Stealth Attack first, returning the monster and possibly making Mine no longer trigger.

Genexwrecker wrote:I hate konami

Cromat wrote:

greg503 wrote:

Cromat wrote:Question #36:

* Opponent's "Sea Stealth Attack" banished "Adamancipator Risen - Dragite" until the End Phase. My opponent argues as Cromat's "Mystic Mine" destroys during End Phase first, and then, I can return of my Synchro monster to the field back while there is no around that Field Spell anymore.
* I argues as that Trap banishes the monster until End Phase, therefore during End Phase, my opponent still has a monster, so my Field Spell will not be destroyed.

- What will happen? (Explain the situation accurately.)

https://www.yugioh-card.com/en/play/fast-effect-timing/
The turn player would have priority to activate an effect, but this also means they have to resolve mandatory effects first (the non-turn player doesn't get priority until an effect(s) that start a chain are activated, or all mandatory things are resolved). If you have the Mine and it is your turn, Mine activates before Sea Stealth Attack returns the Dragite, if you have the Mine and it is not your turn, they should resolve Sea Stealth Attack first, returning the monster and possibly making Mine no longer trigger.

Well, it was my turn. (I just ended my turn, and my opponent activated their Trap's effect by banishing that Synchro Monster..)

Genexwrecker wrote:I hate konami

ouro456 wrote:Question.

Playing some oldschool yugioh, i'm playing pre-eratta Imperial Order. I.O is currently active on the board. Can you activate an equip card at this time and have it stay on the board?

Specifically, he was playing Maha Vailo, he wanted to equip it with a card for the Effect and 500 atk boost. Will I.O negate and send to grave? or will it just negate the attack boost of the spell itself and leave it on board? (I know it doesn't destroy, is the action of equipping to a monster part of the effect of an equip card? Does I.O negate activations, or is it specifically just the effect)

Cromat wrote:Question #37:

Opponent has a "Paleozoic Marrella" on their side of the field as Set while you've a face-up "Macro Cosmos". Opponent activates that Trap.. So.. 1 Trap can go to GY or it will be banished because my "Macro Cosmos" or no Trap can be banished nor sent from Deck?

Cromat wrote:Question #37:

Opponent has a "Paleozoic Marrella" on their side of the field as Set while you've a face-up "Macro Cosmos". Opponent activates that Trap.. So.. 1 Trap can go to GY or it will be banished because my "Macro Cosmos" or no Trap can be banished nor sent from Deck?