Cromat wrote:Question #51:
i;
● Turn Player, during their Main Phase 1: Activates "Red-Eyes Fusion" and Summons "Red-Eyes Dark Dragoon".
● Non-Turn Player activates an Quick Effect of "Labrynth Chandraglier" from their hand and; send "Labrynth Chandraglier" and "Ariane the Labrynth Servant" from their hand to their GY.
● Turn Player, activates Quick Effect of "Red-Eyes Dark Dragoon" by discarding 1 card from their hand for negate effect of "Labrynth Chandraglier".
ii;
● During Turn Player's Main Phase 1: Non-Turn Player activates effect of "Big Welcome Labrynth" by banishing it from their respective GY.
● Turn Players activates Quick Effect of "Red-Eyes Dark Dragoon" for negate that Trap Card's activation.
In both cases mentioned above, Turn Player places 1 Counter on their Fusion Monster.
In both cases mentioned above, non-Turn Player opposes to Turn Player by saying that: "You didn't destroyed them, you can't gain 1000 ATK points."
And non-Turn Player appendices: You can't destroy card(s) which is one(s) already in GY(s). Monster one that I discarded is in my GY now and the Trap was a GY effect. So, remove your Counter(s)."
According to the above 2 situations that "Red-Eyes Dark Dragoon" could be gain 1000 ATK or not?
If the card changed zones as a cost to activate an effect, then it won't be destroyed (see Mechaba rulings), additionally, cards in the GY or banished "zone" can't be destroyed either.