Duelingbook Forum

Lunhill wrote:w.e tbh idc anymore ill play on another platform

Please do.

There are two possibilities here

1. You genuinely don't know about proper psct and rulings, and/or do not understand db etiquette. In which case you need to stop playing rated, study psct, study rulings, learn the difference between costs/effects, etc.

OR

2. You're a troll. You're a pathological liar, and you simply refuse to acknowledge any wrongdoing on your part.

Either way, 300+ games and you still haven't figured it out? How did you even win those games?

troglyte wrote:There are two possibilities here

1. You genuinely don't know about proper psct and rulings, and/or do not understand db etiquette. In which case you need to stop playing rated, study psct, study rulings, learn the difference between costs/effects, etc.

OR

2. You're a troll. You're a pathological liar, and you simply refuse to acknowledge any wrongdoing on your part.

Either way, 300+ games and you still haven't figured it out? How did you even win those games?

Finally. Someone with proper grammar

This argument looks like a debt vs CrystalMusic argument, not going to lie.

TheNastyDoctor wrote:Debt, don't try to defend the judge. Lunhill was totally wrong about the cost, but that isn't a reason to freeze their account for.. 2 weeks? A beginner mode or a warning would've been enough. Even more when there are replays where players do illegal in-game moves while playing rated and judges not even give a warning to them. If issues like this are not resolved, someday the reputation of duelingbook will fall down of a cliff and that's not only bad for people that don't play the game, but for us that enjoy playing in that site.

Keep in mind that penalties add up when you get banned/frozen repeatedly. Lunhill probably would have been frozen for maybe a day, or just 1 week, but because he/she was a repeat offender, the punishment was much harsher.

With that said, for those who don't feel like watching the replay, Wind activated, as chain link 1, the effect of Zoodiac Barrage targeting Zoodiac Ramram (an earth monster), and then Lunhill activated, as chain link 2, the effect of Mudragon of the Swamp (declaring earth) to prevent any more earth monsters from being targeted for the rest of that turn, so the chain resolves, Mudragon's effect resolves, then when Wind attempts to resolve Barrage, Lunhill says earth monsters can't be targeted for the rest of the turn due to Mudragon's effect, which is correct, but then goes on to say that Barrage's effect is now somehow "cancelled" since earth monsters can no longer be targeted, which is incorrect, since the effect to prevent earth monsters from being targeted was applied after the Ramram was already targeted, and not before.

They argue about this back and forth until long story short Resource Judge #9170 comes and freezes Lunhill for being ignorant and lying about a bunch of stuff and not understanding how targeting works.