xXJack_AtlasXx | #1 | Sun Aug 22, 2021 9:47 AM | Delete | In my previous post Total Number of Legal OCG and TCG Cards in Yu-Gi-Oh! Master Duel (As of 08/21/2021) I stated the number of playable cards:
Total Number of Yu-Gi-Oh! cards in the World: 11,350 Cards
Total Number of OCG Cards: 7,508 Monster Cards 2,164 Spell Cards 1,678 Trap Cards 11,350 Cards
Total Number of TCG Cards: 7,223 Monster Cards 2,119 Spell Cards 1,667 Traps Cards 11,009 Cards
While this is great knowledge why does it matter to the Duelist to know such numbers? And how does one even translate such knowledge to be understood and applied in real scenarios of the game, and deck building? You need to know what you're working with and then be able to break down the whole into parts; from there you understand how the parts work alone and together; from here you can then build the natural systems these parts make up or build an original system which applies the same guiding principles of systems.
For starters these numbers at a glance let us know that a majority of the wins will be decided by monsters. And these wins come in one of four ways which I will list from common to super rare:
1) Reduce Opponent's Life Points to Zero (Common). 2) Alternate Win-Condition (Uncommon). 3) Opponent unable to Draw Cards (Rare). 4) Opponent unable to Play Cards (Super Rare).
Therefore your deck must be able to reduce your Opponent's Life Points to 0 should the other three win conditions not be possible to carry out. And to do this effectively you need a large amount of options to choose from as building your Deck may be likened to building a house:
Ceiling (Trap Cards) Walls (Spell Cards) Foundation (Monster Cards) Chief Cornerstone (Key Monster Card)
Before moving further let us look at the ratios and the relationship the numbers share with one another to get a basic idea of what they're communicating:
11,009 Cards ÷ 11,350 Cards = 97% Percent 11,350 Cards - 11, 009 Cards = 341 Card Difference 341 Cards ÷ 11,350 Cards = 3% Percent
We see that the OCG is playing with just 3% Percent more Cards than we are and therefore would be wise to study the trends which arise there. This is crucial if one is to become the "King of Games" for one must win the World Championship to truly gain that title, for at this event the cards playable will be in favor of the OCG.
Let us now look at the Monster, Spell, and Trap Card ratio among both formats:
OCG (Original Card Game) 7,508 Monster Cards ÷ 11,350 Cards = 66% Percent 2,164 Spell Cards ÷ 11,350 Cards = 19% Percent 1,678 Trap Cards ÷ 11,350 Cards = 15% Percent
TCG (Trading Card Game) 7,223 Monster Cards ÷ 11,009 Cards = 66% 2,119 Spell Cards ÷ 11,009 Cards = 19% Percent 1,667 Trap Cards ÷ 11,009 Cards = 15% Percent
Your Decks construction is heavily dependent on the integrity of you Key Monster Card and the Monster Cards as they will hold up the rest of your Deck, and be doing a majority of the work. Therefore Your Deck should always be ready to reduce your Opponent's Life Points to 0 in the event that your other three avenues to victory are unavailable, and in the most pressing of circumstances you must be able to bring the game to a draw. If none of these objectives can be achieved then defeat will be your result. Since both players begin with 8,000 Life Points you must ensure that your Deck can reduce them in one of eight ways:
1) Inflict 8,000 Damage 1 time. 2) Inflict 4,000 Damage 2 times. 3) Inflict 2,000 Damage 4 times. 4) Inflict 1,000 Damage 8 times. 5) Inflict 800 Damage 10 times. 6) Inflict 400 Damage 20 times. 7) Inflict 200 Damage 40 times. 8) Inflict 100 Damage 80 times.
As can be clearly seen the greater the damage you can Inflict the quicker the game will go and the less damage you can Inflict the slower the game will go. Yet on both extreme ends it becomes more difficult to win the higher or lower you go on the scale as you can only inflict damage in two ways:
1) Battle Damage. 2) Effect Damage.
Each of these ways of inflicting damage have three methods by which they may be accomplished:
Battle Damage: 1) Direct Attack. 2) Battle Damage. 3) Direct Damage.
Effect Damage: 1) Monster Card Effect 2) Spell Card Effect 3) Trap Card Effect
Do not be foolish in relying on only one method to Inflict damage to your Opponent's Life Points as you will run into few willing Opponent's who will allow you to do as you please as their objective is also to win against you. That said you cannot rely on always having the Monster with the highest Attack Points or the best Card Effect, therefore your Spell and Trap Cards must work to help eliminate threats by either removing them from the Board or allowing you to get over your Opponent's strongest Monster in Battle. So knowing when you can attack and when you cannot will help you gain victory.
In closing with the tens of thousands of Cards at your disposal your victory is dependent on how well your Deck is built on reducing your Opponent's Life Points to zero if the other three avenues of victory are unavailable to you. Your Key Monster Card is the chief cornerstone; your other Monster Cards will be built around and on top of it to make up the foundation; your Spell Cards act as the walls of your house; and, finally your Trap Cards act as the roof of your house. So if you don't choose the right Key Monster Card for your Deck then it will crack under pressure, and this will cause your foundation to give way, and lead to the collapse of your house. |
|
greg503 | #2 | Sun Aug 22, 2021 3:48 PM | Delete | Or, you know, just look at the top decklists to get a sense of what archtypes and what generic cards are good currently, e.g. A new D. HERO Fusion is winning in the OCG. |
|
xXJack_AtlasXx | #3 | Sun Aug 22, 2021 5:02 PM | Delete | [quote="greg503":1ryrbwx4]Or, you know, just look at the top decklists to get a sense of what archtypes and what generic cards are good currently, e.g. A new D. HERO Fusion is winning in the OCG.[/quote:1ryrbwx4] Yes and I did mention that briefly when I said:
"Before moving further let us look at the ratios and the relationship the numbers share with one another to get a basic idea of what they're communicating:
11,009 Cards ÷ 11,350 Cards = 97% Percent 11,350 Cards - 11, 009 Cards = 341 Card Difference 341 Cards ÷ 11,350 Cards = 3% Percent
We see that the OCG is playing with just 3% Percent more Cards than we are and therefore would be wise to study the trends which arise there. This is crucial if one is to become the "King of Games" for one must win the World Championship to truly gain that title, for at this event the cards playable will be in favor of the OCG."
Other than that thanks for giving your input. This post--along with others that follow--are to help kep the big picture in mind to help Duelists simplify their card choices by making sure they focus on the main objective on how the game is won to begin with rather than aimlessly using whatever the in thing is. |
|
xXJack_AtlasXx | #4 | Sun Aug 22, 2021 5:11 PM | Delete | [quote="greg503":uklxxlzs]Or, you know, just look at the top decklists to get a sense of what archtypes and what generic cards are good currently, e.g. A new D. HERO Fusion is winning in the OCG.[/quote:uklxxlzs] One other thing I forgot to mention is that if you're satisifed with never making it to the World Championship and are content with accomplishing less then that is fine as well. My posts are written with the aim to encourage new and existing players to think bigger and shoot higher than casual play, and especially encourage those who dream of attaining the "King of Games" title by giving them a clear and straightforward path to follow with sound principles to guide them along the way. I really see a lack of yugioh principles in the community and don't want to be talking about "tech cards" or the "hottest trend" like so many others already do.
When I discovered Dueling Book had a special forum called Serious Discussions I found this to be a prime opportunity to be able to discuss the mindset, philosophy, and the history of Yu-Gi-Oh! so that all fellow duelists can actually learn what the narative of the series is trying to teach us about what it really means to be the "King of Games" and how that title is gained or lost. |
|
robinatk | #5 | Mon Aug 23, 2021 4:46 AM | Delete | [quote="xXJack_AtlasXx":2rgmuja1][quote="greg503":2rgmuja1]Or, you know, just look at the top decklists to get a sense of what archtypes and what generic cards are good currently, e.g. A new D. HERO Fusion is winning in the OCG.[/quote:2rgmuja1] One other thing I forgot to mention is that if you're satisifed with never making it to the World Championship and are content with accomplishing less then that is fine as well. My posts are written with the aim to encourage new and existing players to think bigger and shoot higher than casual play, and especially encourage those who dream of attaining the "King of Games" title by giving them a clear and straightforward path to follow with sound principles to guide them along the way. I really see a lack of yugioh principles in the community and don't want to be talking about "tech cards" or the "hottest trend" like so many others already do.
When I discovered Dueling Book had a special forum called Serious Discussions I found this to be a prime opportunity to be able to discuss the mindset, philosophy, and the history of Yu-Gi-Oh! so that all fellow duelists can actually learn what the narative of the series is trying to teach us about what it really means to be the "King of Games" and how that title is gained or lost.[/quote:2rgmuja1]
Show us your World Championship win then |
|
greg503 | #6 | Mon Aug 23, 2021 7:15 AM | Delete | [quote="xXJack_AtlasXx":35jijp97][quote="greg503":35jijp97]Or, you know, just look at the top decklists to get a sense of what archtypes and what generic cards are good currently, e.g. A new D. HERO Fusion is winning in the OCG.[/quote:35jijp97] We see that the OCG is playing with just 3% Percent more Cards than we are and therefore would be wise to study the trends which arise there. This is crucial if one is to become the "King of Games" for one must win the World Championship to truly gain that title, for at this event the cards playable will be in favor of the OCG."[/quote:35jijp97] Last I checked, Worlds is restricted to cards available in both formats, the combined banlist of both formats, and a few more stall cards like Rainbow Life. Neither TCG players, nor OCG players would have an advantage. |
|
xXJack_AtlasXx | #7 | Mon Aug 23, 2021 9:46 AM | Delete | [quote="greg503":3g61100i][quote="xXJack_AtlasXx":3g61100i][quote="greg503":3g61100i]Or, you know, just look at the top decklists to get a sense of what archtypes and what generic cards are good currently, e.g. A new D. HERO Fusion is winning in the OCG.[/quote:3g61100i] We see that the OCG is playing with just 3% Percent more Cards than we are and therefore would be wise to study the trends which arise there. This is crucial if one is to become the "King of Games" for one must win the World Championship to truly gain that title, for at this event the cards playable will be in favor of the OCG."[/quote:3g61100i] Last I checked, Worlds is restricted to cards available in both formats, the combined banlist of both formats, and a few more stall cards like Rainbow Life. Neither TCG players, nor OCG players would have an advantage.[/quote:3g61100i] Here's a link from the Official Yu-Gi-Oh! site which makes it clear that only the Forbidden and Limited List is changed, not the cards available for play by both sides:
World Championship Celebration 2019 Forbidden & Limited Lists For North, Central, and South American Territories [url:3g61100i]https://www.yugioh-card.com/en/events/specialevents/WC_OTS_Celebration_FL_List.html[/url:3g61100i]
This official announcement from Konami means that OCG cards will be played at world's. Therefore if you don't keep up with the trends there as a TCG player you'll be significantly behind because of lack of information and practice with said cards. |
|
greg503 | #8 | Mon Aug 23, 2021 11:21 AM | Delete | Link broke, try putting it in the [url] tag, also how do they expect TCG players to be able to use cards only released in the OCG at time of Worlds? |
|
xXJack_AtlasXx | #9 | Mon Aug 23, 2021 1:09 PM | Delete | [quote="greg503":n7hi5f9h]Link broke, try putting it in the [url] tag, also how do they expect TCG players to be able to use cards only released in the OCG at time of Worlds?[/quote:n7hi5f9h] Okay sorry about the broken link I took your suggestion about putting it in the URL tag, so it should be fine now. As regards the last part of your comment they expect that each duelist will be responsible for studying and testing the OCG cards for themselves if they wish to compete in worlds. Of course they'll be nice and help explain and read cards, but at that level it's expected that the duelist did their homework ahead of time.
So, instead of simply stating my opinion I thought it prudent to give some hard figures that people can work with and reference. While I haven't bothered to run the numbers on the more minute details I believe we can all agree that TCG having only 97% Percent of the picture means that OCG has 100% Percent of the picture with their 3% Percent advantage. To get an idea of what those results translate to real world let's look at some more hard data:
World Championship [url:n7hi5f9h]https://yugioh.fandom.com/wiki/World_Championship[/url:n7hi5f9h]
From 2,003 to 2,019 there have been 16 Yu-Gi-Oh! World Championships
OCG won 12 out of 16 Yu-Gi-Oh! World Championships
TCG won 4 out of 16 Yu-Gi-Oh! World Championships
This means that OCG has won 75% Percent or 3/4 Quarters of the world championships while TCG has only won 25% Percent or 1/4 Quarter of the same events. So, for TCG players to remain ignorant of such a small percentage of cards have led to the results we see today. |
|
robinatk | #10 | Fri Aug 27, 2021 4:48 PM | Delete | [quote="xXJack_AtlasXx":u8lq79os][quote="greg503":u8lq79os]Link broke, try putting it in the [url] tag, also how do they expect TCG players to be able to use cards only released in the OCG at time of Worlds?[/quote:u8lq79os] Okay sorry about the broken link I took your suggestion about putting it in the URL tag, so it should be fine now. As regards the last part of your comment they expect that each duelist will be responsible for studying and testing the OCG cards for themselves if they wish to compete in worlds. Of course they'll be nice and help explain and read cards, but at that level it's expected that the duelist did their homework ahead of time.
So, instead of simply stating my opinion I thought it prudent to give some hard figures that people can work with and reference. While I haven't bothered to run the numbers on the more minute details I believe we can all agree that TCG having only 97% Percent of the picture means that OCG has 100% Percent of the picture with their 3% Percent advantage. To get an idea of what those results translate to real world let's look at some more hard data:
World Championship [url:u8lq79os]https://yugioh.fandom.com/wiki/World_Championship[/url:u8lq79os]
From 2,003 to 2,019 there have been 16 Yu-Gi-Oh! World Championships
OCG won 12 out of 16 Yu-Gi-Oh! World Championships
TCG won 4 out of 16 Yu-Gi-Oh! World Championships
This means that OCG has won 75% Percent or 3/4 Quarters of the world championships while TCG has only won 25% Percent or 1/4 Quarter of the same events. So, for TCG players to remain ignorant of such a small percentage of cards have led to the results we see today.[/quote:u8lq79os]
Even your fandom link proves that OCG only cards are illegal at worlds... only cards released in both versions of the game are legal at worlds. From your stats, the trend we see is that the OCG have better players. That is all. |
|
xXJack_AtlasXx | #11 | Sat Aug 28, 2021 3:06 PM | Delete | [quote="robinatk":27mvpd8k][quote="xXJack_AtlasXx":27mvpd8k][quote="greg503":27mvpd8k]Link broke, try putting it in the [url] tag, also how do they expect TCG players to be able to use cards only released in the OCG at time of Worlds?[/quote:27mvpd8k] Okay sorry about the broken link I took your suggestion about putting it in the URL tag, so it should be fine now. As regards the last part of your comment they expect that each duelist will be responsible for studying and testing the OCG cards for themselves if they wish to compete in worlds. Of course they'll be nice and help explain and read cards, but at that level it's expected that the duelist did their homework ahead of time.
So, instead of simply stating my opinion I thought it prudent to give some hard figures that people can work with and reference. While I haven't bothered to run the numbers on the more minute details I believe we can all agree that TCG having only 97% Percent of the picture means that OCG has 100% Percent of the picture with their 3% Percent advantage. To get an idea of what those results translate to real world let's look at some more hard data:
World Championship [url:27mvpd8k]https://yugioh.fandom.com/wiki/World_Championship[/url:27mvpd8k]
From 2,003 to 2,019 there have been 16 Yu-Gi-Oh! World Championships
OCG won 12 out of 16 Yu-Gi-Oh! World Championships
TCG won 4 out of 16 Yu-Gi-Oh! World Championships
This means that OCG has won 75% Percent or 3/4 Quarters of the world championships while TCG has only won 25% Percent or 1/4 Quarter of the same events. So, for TCG players to remain ignorant of such a small percentage of cards have led to the results we see today.[/quote:27mvpd8k]
Even your fandom link proves that OCG only cards are illegal at worlds... only cards released in both versions of the game are legal at worlds. From your stats, the trend we see is that the OCG have better players. That is all.[/quote:27mvpd8k] If you read the Yu-G-Oh! Fandom link carefully, the "not legal cards in any region" are referring to hard to get cards or cards that come out in exclusives such as the case with Shonen Jump promotional cards. Applying your line of reasoning would mean that since OCG cards are not legal to play in TCG therefore they should not be allowed at world events; and in the same manner since TCG cards are legal in any TCG territory only you can't play them in OCG or world events: therefore your line of reasoning would conclude that no cards could be played at the Yu-Gi-Oh! World Championship.
Here's an official links from Konami clearly explaining card legality: [url:27mvpd8k]https://img.yugioh-card.com/uk/gameplay/detail.php?id=426[/url:27mvpd8k]
As far as the numbers I have shared goes they clearly show that one reason why OCG players are better than TCG players is because they have the complete knowledge base to work with. And for whatever reason TCG players don't want to study this. But, instead of wasting precious time and energy with fault finding others I thought it best to actually gather hard and practical data for all players to benefit from. |
|
Renji Asuka | #12 | Sat Aug 28, 2021 3:26 PM | Delete | The difference in Card Pool isn't the reason.
Asians are typically superior when it comes to gaming in general. We see high success with Asians across every competitive game. |
|
xXJack_AtlasXx | #13 | Sat Aug 28, 2021 3:47 PM | Delete | [quote="Renji Asuka":1fczg8t4]The difference in Card Pool isn't the reason.
Asians are typically superior when it comes to gaming in general. We see high success with Asians across every competitive game.[/quote:1fczg8t4] Cool signature man! I like your "King of Games" flex ha ha. I did state that the card pool difference is only one of the reasons though...not the main reason...still if you look at the patterns between both sides the mindset and diligence also separates them, not some magical inherited skill or something in Asians which makes them superior.
That aside my main point is that to not have the full picture is to be behind. Also the OCG players don't so hyped about shiny cards like TCG players do, and I remember the shock of one of my OCG friends from Japan when he told me that our TCG secret rare Pot of Greed has always been a common in Japan. After that experience I stopped valuing cards based on their shine and rarity but, instead on how they integrated with te Deck as a whole, and how well they accomplished the win condition for the game itself. |
|
DarwisBellium92 | #14 | Sat Aug 28, 2021 5:09 PM | Delete | Mistake: Pot of Duality in OCG (DREV) is common, while in TCG, is Secret Rare No pot of greed |
|
robinatk | #15 | Sat Aug 28, 2021 5:26 PM | Delete | No, you're missunderstanding your own fandom link. The Official link you provided has no relevance on the Worlds Banlist, it purely states which cards are legal in Europe as not all TCG cards release in all TCG locations at the same time. Only cards that exist in both CG's are legal at worlds.
You've already wasted precious time and energy making this post... What impact will this have? If it's purely your opinion (which it is) to say that ALL TCG players do not look at the OCG and learn from them... our formats usually consist of what they've already played tweaked for our F&L list. |
|
robinatk | #16 | Sat Aug 28, 2021 5:29 PM | Delete | [quote="xXJack_AtlasXx":2gxs69kb][quote="Renji Asuka":2gxs69kb]The difference in Card Pool isn't the reason.
Asians are typically superior when it comes to gaming in general. We see high success with Asians across every competitive game.[/quote:2gxs69kb] Cool signature man! I like your "King of Games" flex ha ha. I did state that the card pool difference is only one of the reasons though...not the main reason...still if you look at the patterns between both sides the mindset and diligence also separates them, not some magical inherited skill or something in Asians which makes them superior.
That aside my main point is that to not have the full picture is to be behind. Also the OCG players to don't so hyped about shiny cards like TCG players do, and I remember the shock of one of my OCG friends from Japan when he told me that our TCG secret rare POt of Greed has always been a common in Japan. After that experience I stopped valuing cards based on their shine and rarity but, instead on how they integrated with te Deck as a whole, and how well they accomplished the win condition for the game itself.[/quote:2gxs69kb]
Konami rarity bump key cards from the OCG format. It's not that the TCG players "lIkE sHiNy CaRdS" it's that Konami have seen what cards are sort after in the OCG and bumped them to sell more product. |
|
xXJack_AtlasXx | #17 | Sat Aug 28, 2021 7:23 PM | Delete | [quote="robinatk":1g9wagyx]No, you're missunderstanding your own fandom link. The Official link you provided has no relevance on the Worlds Banlist, it purely states which cards are legal in Europe as not all TCG cards release in all TCG locations at the same time. Only cards that exist in both CG's are legal at worlds.
You've already wasted precious time and energy making this post... What impact will this have? If it's purely your opinion (which it is) to say that ALL TCG players do not look at the OCG and learn from them... our formats usually consist of what they've already played tweaked for our F&L list.[/quote:1g9wagyx] Well if you can think of something better then you can always create your own thread? This is supposed to be a forum about Serious Discussions after all. Otherwise do you have anything meaningful to contribute to this thread? |
|
robinatk | #18 | Sat Aug 28, 2021 7:34 PM | Delete | [quote="xXJack_AtlasXx":rguilym5][quote="robinatk":rguilym5]No, you're missunderstanding your own fandom link. The Official link you provided has no relevance on the Worlds Banlist, it purely states which cards are legal in Europe as not all TCG cards release in all TCG locations at the same time. Only cards that exist in both CG's are legal at worlds.
You've already wasted precious time and energy making this post... What impact will this have? If it's purely your opinion (which it is) to say that ALL TCG players do not look at the OCG and learn from them... our formats usually consist of what they've already played tweaked for our F&L list.[/quote:rguilym5] Well if you can think of something better then you can always create your own thread? This is supposed to be a forum about Serious Discussions after all. Otherwise do you have anything meaningful to contribute to this thread?[/quote:rguilym5]
Just to constantly remind you about what cards are legal in Worlds banlist until you know the correct answer and stop spreading missinformation. And to refute your accusations of the TCG player base when you talk out your rear end. |
|
xXJack_AtlasXx | #19 | Sat Aug 28, 2021 8:59 PM | Delete | [quote="robinatk":4rvvkzos][quote="xXJack_AtlasXx":4rvvkzos][quote="robinatk":4rvvkzos]No, you're missunderstanding your own fandom link. The Official link you provided has no relevance on the Worlds Banlist, it purely states which cards are legal in Europe as not all TCG cards release in all TCG locations at the same time. Only cards that exist in both CG's are legal at worlds.
You've already wasted precious time and energy making this post... What impact will this have? If it's purely your opinion (which it is) to say that ALL TCG players do not look at the OCG and learn from them... our formats usually consist of what they've already played tweaked for our F&L list.[/quote:4rvvkzos] Well if you can think of something better then you can always create your own thread? This is supposed to be a forum about Serious Discussions after all. Otherwise do you have anything meaningful to contribute to this thread?[/quote:4rvvkzos]
Just to constantly remind you about what cards are legal in Worlds banlist until you know the correct answer and stop spreading missinformation. And to refute your accusations of the TCG player base when you talk out your rear end.[/quote:4rvvkzos] So are you saying that the shoe fits you? All I'm getting from your posts is that you're triggered. |
|
greg503 | #20 | Sun Aug 29, 2021 8:01 AM | Delete | [quote="xXJack_AtlasXx":38b19yax][quote="robinatk":38b19yax][quote="xXJack_AtlasXx":38b19yax] Well if you can think of something better then you can always create your own thread? This is supposed to be a forum about Serious Discussions after all. Otherwise do you have anything meaningful to contribute to this thread?[/quote:38b19yax]
Just to constantly remind you about what cards are legal in Worlds banlist until you know the correct answer and stop spreading missinformation. And to refute your accusations of the TCG player base when you talk out your rear end.[/quote:38b19yax] So are you saying that the shoe fits you? All I'm getting from your posts is that you're triggered.[/quote:38b19yax] Why would the let region exclusive cards in Worlds? |
|
xXJack_AtlasXx | #21 | Sun Aug 29, 2021 8:09 AM | Delete | [quote="greg503":3fjsolw4][quote="xXJack_AtlasXx":3fjsolw4][quote="robinatk":3fjsolw4]
Just to constantly remind you about what cards are legal in Worlds banlist until you know the correct answer and stop spreading missinformation. And to refute your accusations of the TCG player base when you talk out your rear end.[/quote:3fjsolw4] So are you saying that the shoe fits you? All I'm getting from your posts is that you're triggered.[/quote:3fjsolw4] Why would the let region exclusive cards in Worlds?[/quote:3fjsolw4] They don't which is why I'm confused by what he's saying. |
|
robinatk | #22 | Sun Aug 29, 2021 10:57 AM | Delete | [quote="greg503":2fh9ntlh][quote="xXJack_AtlasXx":2fh9ntlh][quote="robinatk":2fh9ntlh]
Just to constantly remind you about what cards are legal in Worlds banlist until you know the correct answer and stop spreading missinformation. And to refute your accusations of the TCG player base when you talk out your rear end.[/quote:2fh9ntlh] So are you saying that the shoe fits you? All I'm getting from your posts is that you're triggered.[/quote:2fh9ntlh] Why would the let region exclusive cards in Worlds?[/quote:2fh9ntlh]
They don't, OP just doesn't know that |
|
greg503 | #23 | Mon Aug 30, 2021 9:01 AM | Delete | [quote="xXJack_AtlasXx":1533bvqa][quote="greg503":1533bvqa][quote="xXJack_AtlasXx":1533bvqa] So are you saying that the shoe fits you? All I'm getting from your posts is that you're triggered.[/quote:1533bvqa] Why would the let region exclusive cards in Worlds?[/quote:1533bvqa] They don't which is why I'm confused by what he's saying.[/quote:1533bvqa] YOU acted like they did |
|
Renji Asuka | #24 | Mon Aug 30, 2021 10:34 AM | Delete | Just saying, there's a lot of vanilla monsters that are OCG only that never get used. |
|
greg503 | #25 | Mon Aug 30, 2021 2:07 PM | Delete | #ImportAirEater |
|
xXJack_AtlasXx | #26 | Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:11 PM | Delete | [quote="greg503":39nt1wxb][quote="xXJack_AtlasXx":39nt1wxb][quote="greg503":39nt1wxb] Why would the let region exclusive cards in Worlds?[/quote:39nt1wxb] They don't which is why I'm confused by what he's saying.[/quote:39nt1wxb] YOU acted like they did[/quote:39nt1wxb] Maybe that's what you assumed I said, but in reality I said nothing of the sort. |
|
greg503 | #27 | Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:23 PM | Delete | [quote="xXJack_AtlasXx":2da38dw3][quote="greg503":2da38dw3] Last I checked, Worlds is restricted to cards available in both formats, the combined banlist of both formats, and a few more stall cards like Rainbow Life. Neither TCG players, nor OCG players would have an advantage.[/quote:2da38dw3] Here's a link from the Official Yu-Gi-Oh! site which makes it clear that only the Forbidden and Limited List is changed, not the cards available for play by both sides:
World Championship Celebration 2019 Forbidden & Limited Lists For North, Central, and South American Territories [url:2da38dw3]https://www.yugioh-card.com/en/events/specialevents/WC_OTS_Celebration_FL_List.html[/url:2da38dw3]
This official announcement from Konami means that OCG cards will be played at world's. Therefore if you don't keep up with the trends there as a TCG player you'll be significantly behind because of lack of information and practice with said cards.[/quote:2da38dw3] This is where you said that "only the Forbidden and Limited List is changed, not the cards available for play by both sides." |
|
greg503 | #28 | Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:27 PM | Delete | https://www.yugioh-card.com/en/events/s ... _FAQs.htmlI dug into the FAQs and discovered that "An exception has been made for this event since the 2019 Yu-Gi-Oh! World Championship competitors will be able to use both OCG and TCG cards in their Decks" meaning that this is true for 2019. We'd have to go a bit further to see if things actually changed. |
|
xXJack_AtlasXx | #29 | Tue Aug 31, 2021 10:20 AM | Delete | [quote="greg503":sy9qp0zt]https://www.yugioh-card.com/en/events/s ... _FAQs.html I dug into the FAQs and discovered that "An exception has been made for this event since the 2019 Yu-Gi-Oh! World Championship competitors will be able to use both OCG and TCG cards in their Decks" meaning that this is true for 2019. We'd have to go a bit further to see if things actually changed.[/quote:sy9qp0zt] Well if you have been playing since the International release of Yu-Gi-Oh! since around 2002 then you would know that prior to Konami officially making the rules or hosting tournaments everything was done by Upper Deck Entertainment (UDE) and this was prior to the first Forbidden & Limited list which wouldn't come out until around 2004. From that time until 2008 Yu-Gi-Oh! was under the control of UDE before being taken over by Konami, specifically Konami Digital Entertinment (KDE); so from 2004 OCG and TCG had the same Forbidden & Limited lists until 2013. This means that the OCG and TCG have had separate ban lists for the past 8 Years.
Again from the history of the game and using common sense it doesn't take a rocket scientist to understand that a difference in card access and availability would lead to a gap of knowledge and experience between OCG and TCG players. Therefore for worlds to successfully have a fair duel = fair play occur there would be a need to make a special ban list for such a special event, and it would only make sense to exclude promotional or hard to obtain cards which aren't available in all regions of players on both sides.
Anyways I am not sure what point you wish to make with regards to what you've been posting... |
|
xXJack_AtlasXx | #30 | Tue Aug 31, 2021 10:34 AM | Delete | [quote="greg503":94nhlf3l][quote="xXJack_AtlasXx":94nhlf3l][quote="greg503":94nhlf3l] Last I checked, Worlds is restricted to cards available in both formats, the combined banlist of both formats, and a few more stall cards like Rainbow Life. Neither TCG players, nor OCG players would have an advantage.[/quote:94nhlf3l] Here's a link from the Official Yu-Gi-Oh! site which makes it clear that only the Forbidden and Limited List is changed, not the cards available for play by both sides:
World Championship Celebration 2019 Forbidden & Limited Lists For North, Central, and South American Territories [url:94nhlf3l]https://www.yugioh-card.com/en/events/specialevents/WC_OTS_Celebration_FL_List.html[/url:94nhlf3l]
This official announcement from Konami means that OCG cards will be played at world's. Therefore if you don't keep up with the trends there as a TCG player you'll be significantly behind because of lack of information and practice with said cards.[/quote:94nhlf3l] This is where you said that "only the Forbidden and Limited List is changed, not the cards available for play by both sides."[/quote:94nhlf3l] And I only made the point that OCG and TCG cards would be playable at worlds. I never said anything about promotional cards: this is something you assumed. My repsonse to you was simply to point out that OCG wouldn't ban their own cards just because TCG had never had them. Afterall if TCG players wanted to test the OCG cards out prior to their official release in their respective countries they could simply get the translation of the card and make a proxy to play with, which many players have done since the game has been around.
Kazuki Takhashi created Yu-Gi-Oh! around 1995 and the card game was officially out in Japan around 1999. Seeing that TCG received the game in 2002 and the first Yu-Gi-Oh! World Championship was held around 2003 shows that it didn't really take much time for TCG players to catch on or compete. I personally would like to see the scales in the Yu-Gi-Oh! World Championship tilt more in favor of TCG, but it can't be helped if TCG players have their attention divided and elsewhere. |
|
BoomerDuels | #31 | Tue Oct 12, 2021 9:08 PM | Delete | [quote="xXJack_AtlasXx":3frde6f1]In my previous post Total Number of Legal OCG and TCG Cards in Yu-Gi-Oh! Master Duel (As of 08/21/2021) I stated the number of playable cards:
Total Number of Yu-Gi-Oh! cards in the World: 11,350 Cards
Total Number of OCG Cards: 7,508 Monster Cards 2,164 Spell Cards 1,678 Trap Cards 11,350 Cards
Total Number of TCG Cards: 7,223 Monster Cards 2,119 Spell Cards 1,667 Traps Cards 11,009 Cards
While this is great knowledge why does it matter to the Duelist to know such numbers? And how does one even translate such knowledge to be understood and applied in real scenarios of the game, and deck building? You need to know what you're working with and then be able to break down the whole into parts; from there you understand how the parts work alone and together; from here you can then build the natural systems these parts make up or build an original system which applies the same guiding principles of systems.
For starters these numbers at a glance let us know that a majority of the wins will be decided by monsters. And these wins come in one of four ways which I will list from common to super rare:
1) Reduce Opponent's Life Points to Zero (Common). 2) Alternate Win-Condition (Uncommon). 3) Opponent unable to Draw Cards (Rare). 4) Opponent unable to Play Cards (Super Rare).
Therefore your deck must be able to reduce your Opponent's Life Points to 0 should the other three win conditions not be possible to carry out. And to do this effectively you need a large amount of options to choose from as building your Deck may be likened to building a house:
Ceiling (Trap Cards) Walls (Spell Cards) Foundation (Monster Cards) Chief Cornerstone (Key Monster Card)
Before moving further let us look at the ratios and the relationship the numbers share with one another to get a basic idea of what they're communicating:
11,009 Cards ÷ 11,350 Cards = 97% Percent 11,350 Cards - 11, 009 Cards = 341 Card Difference 341 Cards ÷ 11,350 Cards = 3% Percent
We see that the OCG is playing with just 3% Percent more Cards than we are and therefore would be wise to study the trends which arise there. This is crucial if one is to become the "King of Games" for one must win the World Championship to truly gain that title, for at this event the cards playable will be in favor of the OCG.
Let us now look at the Monster, Spell, and Trap Card ratio among both formats:
OCG (Original Card Game) 7,508 Monster Cards ÷ 11,350 Cards = 66% Percent 2,164 Spell Cards ÷ 11,350 Cards = 19% Percent 1,678 Trap Cards ÷ 11,350 Cards = 15% Percent
TCG (Trading Card Game) 7,223 Monster Cards ÷ 11,009 Cards = 66% 2,119 Spell Cards ÷ 11,009 Cards = 19% Percent 1,667 Trap Cards ÷ 11,009 Cards = 15% Percent
Your Decks construction is heavily dependent on the integrity of you Key Monster Card and the Monster Cards as they will hold up the rest of your Deck, and be doing a majority of the work. Therefore Your Deck should always be ready to reduce your Opponent's Life Points to 0 in the event that your other three avenues to victory are unavailable, and in the most pressing of circumstances you must be able to bring the game to a draw. If none of these objectives can be achieved then defeat will be your result. Since both players begin with 8,000 Life Points you must ensure that your Deck can reduce them in one of eight ways:
1) Inflict 8,000 Damage 1 time. 2) Inflict 4,000 Damage 2 times. 3) Inflict 2,000 Damage 4 times. 4) Inflict 1,000 Damage 8 times. 5) Inflict 800 Damage 10 times. 6) Inflict 400 Damage 20 times. 7) Inflict 200 Damage 40 times. 8) Inflict 100 Damage 80 times.
As can be clearly seen the greater the damage you can Inflict the quicker the game will go and the less damage you can Inflict the slower the game will go. Yet on both extreme ends it becomes more difficult to win the higher or lower you go on the scale as you can only inflict damage in two ways:
1) Battle Damage. 2) Effect Damage.
Each of these ways of inflicting damage have three methods by which they may be accomplished:
Battle Damage: 1) Direct Attack. 2) Battle Damage. 3) Direct Damage.
Effect Damage: 1) Monster Card Effect 2) Spell Card Effect 3) Trap Card Effect
Do not be foolish in relying on only one method to Inflict damage to your Opponent's Life Points as you will run into few willing Opponent's who will allow you to do as you please as their objective is also to win against you. That said you cannot rely on always having the Monster with the highest Attack Points or the best Card Effect, therefore your Spell and Trap Cards must work to help eliminate threats by either removing them from the Board or allowing you to get over your Opponent's strongest Monster in Battle. So knowing when you can attack and when you cannot will help you gain victory.
In closing with the tens of thousands of Cards at your disposal your victory is dependent on how well your Deck is built on reducing your Opponent's Life Points to zero if the other three avenues of victory are unavailable to you. Your Key Monster Card is the chief cornerstone; your other Monster Cards will be built around and on top of it to make up the foundation; your Spell Cards act as the walls of your house; and, finally your Trap Cards act as the roof of your house. So if you don't choose the right Key Monster Card for your Deck then it will crack under pressure, and this will cause your foundation to give way, and lead to the collapse of your house.[/quote:3frde6f1]
Lol this is very vague For one you should never have life points as the main focus of your games, the entire aim of the game is to maintain card advantage, winning and reducong your opponent's life points to Zero will be something you simply stumble across.
The OCG has a radically different banlist and card pool than the TCG so it should not necesarily be used to see the meta n the TCG |
|
greg503 | #32 | Wed Oct 13, 2021 7:17 AM | Delete | [quote="BoomerDuels":9ngnkqtx]For one you should never have life points as the main focus of your games, the entire aim of the game is to maintain card advantage, winning and [reducing] your opponent's life points to Zero will be something you simply stumble across.[/quote:9ngnkqtx] Remember all those times in the Progression Series Gage activated Destrudo only to get OTK'd next turn? |
|
BoomerDuels | #33 | Wed Oct 13, 2021 11:12 PM | Delete | [quote="greg503":24u53gag][quote="BoomerDuels":24u53gag]For one you should never have life points as the main focus of your games, the entire aim of the game is to maintain card advantage, winning and [reducing] your opponent's life points to Zero will be something you simply stumble across.[/quote:24u53gag] Remember all those times in the Progression Series Gage activated Destrudo only to get OTK'd next turn?[/quote:24u53gag]
.... For 1 gage misplays like Shit
And for another - The entire aim of the game is card advantage. Life points don't matter
Go to any YCS and tell me otherwise |
|
Renji Asuka | #34 | Thu Oct 14, 2021 1:52 AM | Delete | [quote="BoomerDuels":97jiu323][quote="greg503":97jiu323][quote="BoomerDuels":97jiu323]For one you should never have life points as the main focus of your games, the entire aim of the game is to maintain card advantage, winning and [reducing] your opponent's life points to Zero will be something you simply stumble across.[/quote:97jiu323] Remember all those times in the Progression Series Gage activated Destrudo only to get OTK'd next turn?[/quote:97jiu323]
.... For 1 gage misplays like Shit
And for another - The entire aim of the game is card advantage. Life points don't matter
Go to any YCS and tell me otherwise[/quote:97jiu323] LP very much matters in the game. Here's why. You can play Solemn Judgment, then Solemn Warning, then get finished off by a Cyber Dragon just sayin... |
|
greg503 | #35 | Thu Oct 14, 2021 11:32 AM | Delete | [quote="BoomerDuels":3hlum2bd][quote="greg503":3hlum2bd][quote="BoomerDuels":3hlum2bd]For one you should never have life points as the main focus of your games, the entire aim of the game is to maintain card advantage, winning and [reducing] your opponent's life points to Zero will be something you simply stumble across.[/quote:3hlum2bd] Remember all those times in the Progression Series Gage activated Destrudo only to get OTK'd next turn?[/quote:3hlum2bd]
.... For 1 gage misplays like Shit
And for another - The entire aim of the game is card advantage. Life points don't matter
Go to any YCS and tell me otherwise[/quote:3hlum2bd] Go to any YCS and ask them if they DON'T win via damage |
|
BoomerDuels | #36 | Sat Oct 16, 2021 10:17 PM | Delete | [quote="greg503":2ypp56ma][quote="BoomerDuels":2ypp56ma][quote="greg503":2ypp56ma] Remember all those times in the Progression Series Gage activated Destrudo only to get OTK'd next turn?[/quote:2ypp56ma]
.... For 1 gage misplays like Shit
And for another - The entire aim of the game is card advantage. Life points don't matter
Go to any YCS and tell me otherwise[/quote:2ypp56ma] Go to any YCS and ask them if they DON'T win via damage[/quote:2ypp56ma]
So none of you here know what you are talking about Sure - Damage i technically the way you *win* the game But achieving that requires focusing your deck solely on card advantage Why are sky strikers such a good deck? |
|
greg503 | #37 | Sun Oct 17, 2021 8:04 AM | Delete | [quote="BoomerDuels":2y9o2ket][quote="greg503":2y9o2ket][quote="BoomerDuels":2y9o2ket]
.... For 1 gage misplays like Shit
And for another - The entire aim of the game is card advantage. Life points don't matter
Go to any YCS and tell me otherwise[/quote:2y9o2ket] Go to any YCS and ask them if they DON'T win via damage[/quote:2y9o2ket]
So none of you here know what you are talking about Sure - Damage i technically the way you *win* the game But achieving that requires focusing your deck solely on card advantage Why are sky strikers such a good deck?[/quote:2y9o2ket] You mean why were they such a good deck, in fact, why was Mine Burn a good deck again? |
|
Renji Asuka | #38 | Sun Oct 17, 2021 8:36 AM | Delete | [quote="BoomerDuels":xpcvygjy][quote="greg503":xpcvygjy][quote="BoomerDuels":xpcvygjy]
.... For 1 gage misplays like Shit
And for another - The entire aim of the game is card advantage. Life points don't matter
Go to any YCS and tell me otherwise[/quote:xpcvygjy] Go to any YCS and ask them if they DON'T win via damage[/quote:xpcvygjy]
So none of you here know what you are talking about Sure - Damage i technically the way you *win* the game But achieving that requires focusing your deck solely on card advantage Why are sky strikers such a good deck?[/quote:xpcvygjy] There's a reason why some players played through Maxx "C" cause they knew they could win that turn.
Card Advantage while important, it is not the end all be all. |
|
BoomerDuels | #39 | Sun Oct 17, 2021 8:53 PM | Delete | [quote="Renji Asuka":31x4p8qe][quote="BoomerDuels":31x4p8qe][quote="greg503":31x4p8qe] Go to any YCS and ask them if they DON'T win via damage[/quote:31x4p8qe]
So none of you here know what you are talking about Sure - Damage i technically the way you *win* the game But achieving that requires focusing your deck solely on card advantage Why are sky strikers such a good deck?[/quote:31x4p8qe] There's a reason why some players played through Maxx "C" cause they knew they could win that turn.
Card Advantage while important, it is not the end all be all.[/quote:31x4p8qe]
Well ye but this dude said it was less important than life points |
|
Renji Asuka | #40 | Sun Oct 17, 2021 9:17 PM | Delete | [quote="BoomerDuels":32bbsyf9][quote="Renji Asuka":32bbsyf9][quote="BoomerDuels":32bbsyf9]
So none of you here know what you are talking about Sure - Damage i technically the way you *win* the game But achieving that requires focusing your deck solely on card advantage Why are sky strikers such a good deck?[/quote:32bbsyf9] There's a reason why some players played through Maxx "C" cause they knew they could win that turn.
Card Advantage while important, it is not the end all be all.[/quote:32bbsyf9]
Well ye but this dude said it was less important than life points[/quote:32bbsyf9] That's because Life Point management is very important especially since you can lose to time in tournaments. |
|
BoomerDuels | #41 | Mon Oct 18, 2021 3:42 PM | Delete | [quote="Renji Asuka":3imggsnv][quote="BoomerDuels":3imggsnv][quote="Renji Asuka":3imggsnv] There's a reason why some players played through Maxx "C" cause they knew they could win that turn.
Card Advantage while important, it is not the end all be all.[/quote:3imggsnv]
Well ye but this dude said it was less important than life points[/quote:3imggsnv] That's because Life Point management is very important especially since you can lose to time in tournaments.[/quote:3imggsnv]
Aight lmao
There is no way you are saying winning in time > card advantage |
|
Renji Asuka | #42 | Mon Oct 18, 2021 5:05 PM | Delete | [quote="BoomerDuels":kcjltr89][quote="Renji Asuka":kcjltr89][quote="BoomerDuels":kcjltr89]
Well ye but this dude said it was less important than life points[/quote:kcjltr89] That's because Life Point management is very important especially since you can lose to time in tournaments.[/quote:kcjltr89]
Aight lmao
There is no way you are saying winning in time > card advantage[/quote:kcjltr89] You can have 15 cards in hand and still lose to time lmao |
|
greg503 | #43 | Tue Oct 19, 2021 3:46 PM | Delete | [quote="BoomerDuels":2g4a6xhn][quote="Renji Asuka":2g4a6xhn][quote="BoomerDuels":2g4a6xhn]
Well ye but this dude said it was less important than life points[/quote:2g4a6xhn] That's because Life Point management is very important especially since you can lose to time in tournaments.[/quote:2g4a6xhn]
Aight lmao
There is no way you are saying winning in time > card advantage[/quote:2g4a6xhn] Winning doesn't care about how many cards you're holding |
|
BoomerDuels | #44 | Tue Oct 19, 2021 4:48 PM | Delete | [quote="greg503":1ufwr6zz][quote="BoomerDuels":1ufwr6zz][quote="Renji Asuka":1ufwr6zz] That's because Life Point management is very important especially since you can lose to time in tournaments.[/quote:1ufwr6zz]
Aight lmao
There is no way you are saying winning in time > card advantage[/quote:1ufwr6zz] Winning doesn't care about how many cards you're holding[/quote:1ufwr6zz]
Lol you really don't knpow what you are talking bout huh? Card Advantage id perhaps the most important thing |
|
Renji Asuka | #45 | Tue Oct 19, 2021 5:04 PM | Delete | [quote="BoomerDuels":3lfob99j][quote="greg503":3lfob99j][quote="BoomerDuels":3lfob99j]
Aight lmao
There is no way you are saying winning in time > card advantage[/quote:3lfob99j] Winning doesn't care about how many cards you're holding[/quote:3lfob99j]
Lol you really don't knpow what you are talking bout huh? Card Advantage id perhaps the most important thing[/quote:3lfob99j] Lol
Maxx "C" challenge would like to have a word with you. |
|
BoomerDuels | #46 | Tue Oct 19, 2021 6:39 PM | Delete | [quote="Renji Asuka":19yovi67][quote="BoomerDuels":19yovi67][quote="greg503":19yovi67] Winning doesn't care about how many cards you're holding[/quote:19yovi67]
Lol you really don't knpow what you are talking bout huh? Card Advantage id perhaps the most important thing[/quote:19yovi67] Lol
Maxx "C" challenge would like to have a word with you.[/quote:19yovi67]
Are you actually going to say that winning in time > Card advantage tho |
|
Renji Asuka | #47 | Tue Oct 19, 2021 6:45 PM | Delete | [quote="BoomerDuels":61jdx16j][quote="Renji Asuka":61jdx16j][quote="BoomerDuels":61jdx16j]
Lol you really don't knpow what you are talking bout huh? Card Advantage id perhaps the most important thing[/quote:61jdx16j] Lol
Maxx "C" challenge would like to have a word with you.[/quote:61jdx16j]
Are you actually going to say that winning in time > Card advantage tho[/quote:61jdx16j] What I'm saying is, Maxx "C" is the perfect example that you can draw all the cards you want and still lose. Whether by Life Points or by Time. |
|
greg503 | #48 | Tue Oct 19, 2021 7:20 PM | Delete | [quote="BoomerDuels":1fxo3k2i][quote="Renji Asuka":1fxo3k2i][quote="BoomerDuels":1fxo3k2i]
Lol you really don't knpow what you are talking bout huh? Card Advantage id perhaps the most important thing[/quote:1fxo3k2i] Lol
Maxx "C" challenge would like to have a word with you.[/quote:1fxo3k2i]
Are you actually going to say that winning in time > Card advantage tho[/quote:1fxo3k2i] Pot of Desires/Extrav draw into additional copies of them, or worse, Garnets. I'd rather be neutral with Prosperity to look at 1 or 4 extra cards and find something USEFUL. |
|
BoomerDuels | #49 | Tue Oct 19, 2021 7:40 PM | Delete | [quote="greg503":16q5807p][quote="BoomerDuels":16q5807p][quote="Renji Asuka":16q5807p] Lol
Maxx "C" challenge would like to have a word with you.[/quote:16q5807p]
Are you actually going to say that winning in time > Card advantage tho[/quote:16q5807p] Pot of Desires/Extrav draw into additional copies of them, or worse, Garnets. I'd rather be neutral with Prosperity to look at 1 or 4 extra cards and find something USEFUL.[/quote:16q5807p]
The consistency and card advantage that desires gives you outeighs the drawback of potentially drawing into more copies of desires
Think of it this way You either A) Activate desires - It gets ashes - 1 for 1 deal B) Activate desires - It doesnt get negated - 1 for 2
You are guaranteed to go +1 You are not guaranteed to draw garnets |
|
greg503 | #50 | Tue Oct 19, 2021 8:04 PM | Delete | [quote="BoomerDuels":2zjp7g70][quote="greg503":2zjp7g70][quote="BoomerDuels":2zjp7g70]
Are you actually going to say that winning in time > Card advantage tho[/quote:2zjp7g70] Pot of Desires/Extrav draw into additional copies of them, or worse, Garnets. I'd rather be neutral with Prosperity to look at 1 or 4 extra cards and find something USEFUL.[/quote:2zjp7g70]
The consistency and card advantage that desires gives you outeighs the drawback of potentially drawing into more copies of desires
Think of it this way You either A) Activate desires - It gets ashes - 1 for 1 deal B) Activate desires - It doesnt get negated - 1 for 2
You are guaranteed to go +1 You are not guaranteed to draw garnets[/quote:2zjp7g70] In Magic, a mechanic called scry allows you to look at the top of your deck and stack it, putting cards you don't want to the bottom. They generally put 2 scrys on the same level as drawing 1. This is because it is important to have relevant cards at your disposal. Prosperity allows to look at up to 6 cards, and draw 1 of them, making it 4 cards in value if not negated, compared to Desires' 2. Don't measure a card's value solely on how plus it allows you to go, otherwise, Ojamagic would be meta. |
|
BoomerDuels | #51 | Wed Oct 20, 2021 12:06 AM | Delete | [quote="greg503":25jkcw8b][quote="BoomerDuels":25jkcw8b][quote="greg503":25jkcw8b] Pot of Desires/Extrav draw into additional copies of them, or worse, Garnets. I'd rather be neutral with Prosperity to look at 1 or 4 extra cards and find something USEFUL.[/quote:25jkcw8b]
The consistency and card advantage that desires gives you outeighs the drawback of potentially drawing into more copies of desires
Think of it this way You either A) Activate desires - It gets ashes - 1 for 1 deal B) Activate desires - It doesnt get negated - 1 for 2
You are guaranteed to go +1 You are not guaranteed to draw garnets[/quote:25jkcw8b] In Magic, a mechanic called scry allows you to look at the top of your deck and stack it, putting cards you don't want to the bottom. They generally put 2 scrys on the same level as drawing 1. This is because it is important to have relevant cards at your disposal. Prosperity allows to look at up to 6 cards, and draw 1 of them, making it 4 cards in value if not negated, compared to Desires' 2. Don't measure a card's value solely on how plus it allows you to go, otherwise, Ojamagic would be meta.[/quote:25jkcw8b]
I never said Desires is better than prosperity But it is not a bad card like you say it is |
|
greg503 | #52 | Wed Oct 20, 2021 6:45 AM | Delete | [quote="BoomerDuels":rqwyr6yw][quote="greg503":rqwyr6yw][quote="BoomerDuels":rqwyr6yw]
The consistency and card advantage that desires gives you outeighs the drawback of potentially drawing into more copies of desires
Think of it this way You either A) Activate desires - It gets ashes - 1 for 1 deal B) Activate desires - It doesnt get negated - 1 for 2
You are guaranteed to go +1 You are not guaranteed to draw garnets[/quote:rqwyr6yw] In Magic, a mechanic called scry allows you to look at the top of your deck and stack it, putting cards you don't want to the bottom. They generally put 2 scrys on the same level as drawing 1. This is because it is important to have relevant cards at your disposal. Prosperity allows to look at up to 6 cards, and draw 1 of them, making it 4 cards in value if not negated, compared to Desires' 2. Don't measure a card's value solely on how plus it allows you to go, otherwise, Ojamagic would be meta.[/quote:rqwyr6yw]
I never said Desires is better than prosperity But it is not a bad card like you say it is[/quote:rqwyr6yw] I never said it was bad, I said it was "worse than." But I guess we both had a bit of a misunderstanding... |
|