Duelingbook Forum

I think you're trying to look at this from a purely game-mechanical perspective when it's really only going to be visible from a policy-related lens. From a purely game-mechanical perspective, I could also argue that the game doesn't allow for illegal plays to be made or for a player to be playing ...

how is choosing an xyz monster then overlaying its materials for its summon not a commitment in your eyes? You have done everything related to a commitment of summoning the monster all that is left is to place it on top of the pile of xyz material you have created for its specific summon. How is no...

The ruling isnt going to be consistent as stated by marshie every situation is different. as for overlaying them to perform a link summon I do not think I have seen a single player do this in over 17000 judge calls on the website. It would be very odd for a player to overlay when not performing an ...

Lots of good questions and topics coming out of this. I appreciate this discussion. Cards don't move by themselves, hence why my Judges on DB are instructed to rule that if you overlay two monsters, you have committed to performing an Xyz Summon. The most accurate comparison to this in real-life ev...

You cannot possibly compare misclicks to a player intentionally performing the action then going back to think more. You can when the intent isn't clear. What's to say I didn't missclick the overlay and instead of clicking out I just decided to overlay and then send them to grave to perform a LInk ...

I do not care what happened at X event. That applies to that event only. You should never be moving cards if you arent making a play. If you overlay it is clear you have started an xyz summon. I never said you did. I'm saying that it's ruled differently at other events. I never said you had to foll...

I do not care what happened at X event. That applies to that event only. You should never be moving cards if you arent making a play. If you overlay it is clear you have started an xyz summon. I never said you did. I'm saying that it's ruled differently at other events. I never said you had to foll...

The moment you start moving cards you are no longer thinking you are making a play. In your case the play is an xyz summon and you must complete it Seems like a weird ruling. Back during Nekroz format, every event I went to ruled that you did not commit to banishing the cards for effect unless you ...

I got into a disagreement in a ranked game about moving cards around. Context, I was playing Spright and my opponent was playing some Runick deck. I ended up clearing his board and then had 3 level 2 monsters on board after he Judgmented the Zeus. I then proceeded to pick up monsters and overlay the...