Duelingbook Forum

When ending m1 does the turn player have to say which phase they are trying to enter?

Thanks

in

Imagine wanting my judgement on a situation to be something that's not my judgement. I see what you mean but in response I would just say it would still be your judgement, in a way perhaps. For instance, the predetermined values of Factor 2 (the maximum accepted time for How long it takes Player B ...

If you don't want generalized responses then don't post a generalized topic. Your suggestions are all for things on the site that are down to a judges judgment and We judges are free to rule things differently and that is perfectly fine the only thing that should always be consistent is actual game...

I did respond to 33 you seem to misunderstand something. Let me get this straight… You’re saying you did in fact read all of my post # 33 and understood it as well? Ok… I won’t argue with you on that However, you have again tried to generalize everything that I’m saying. Please, I can only request,...

You don’t take judge calls more have you taken thousands of misclick calls there are far more than 2 factors considered in every scenario and every misclick is different no 2 are the same. As I said before the standard is to communicate failure to do so is specifically why the judges exist. Genexwr...

----Also on a side note players should be strongly advised to visit the rules and penalties page of this site( (for instance the first thing in announcements) so they don’t get frozen etc. for something they did not mean maliciously - I don't believe that non regular players are that aware and shou...

Renji brother, You refuse to answer my question. Again, please answer my question first as Genexwrecker just did. Genexwreker Thank you so much for answering my point. Ok, how about lets just think from a judges perspective only. Correct me if I’m wrong, I think every judge on this site would agree ...

And I will ask you to stop repeating yourself as well. I have already stated there is a standard to communicate and follow the rules when you don’t is why judges are here. We exist for the reason of people failing to communicate properly. Those communication cases are always up to our judgement bec...

Genexwrecker, Perhaps I’m still not clear enough. Also, please actually try to respond to the points that I make rather than making general statements about why judges exist etc. I feel like I'm being pretty much completely ignored by both of you. I was repeating to Renji because he too also complet...

Appealing is a general method that allows Rulings to be more consistent and fair. It is NOT a solution to this specific issue of miscommunication. Also I feel, you are still trying to avoid the point that I made…. Perhaps think as if you have come to judge a miscommunication issue in-game and now HA...

Please... Again...address the point that i made. You are still not addressing the point that I made last to you! I'll try to make more clear for you. Also, perhaps think of it in a judges perspective as well rather than just a player's perspective. You acknowledged as well in a previous reply of you...

Renji, Please stop saying the same thing over and over again without addressing the other's points. If you see my previous reply to you, I specifically asked "Do you want these judgments that take place every day regarding miscommunication to be fair and consistent (especially when its easily p...

This is not about misc-clicks anymore if you read my #12 on this topic. Perhaps i was not clear enough (I have not talked about mis-clicks after #10 on this topic). This is only concerning the miscommunication that takes place when people do not respond in time etc. There are only a limited amount o...

Renji, I guess you mean there "shouldn't" be any miscommunication - Also Genexwrecker please hear me out... The point is... Do you want these judgments that take place every day regarding miscommunication to be fair and consistent (especially when its easily possible to do so by the existe...

I'm not saying/advocating for how much you should wait before continuing... Ideally everyone would reply after every effect and ideally every person will wait for a response for every effect that they choose to declare.... but this just does not happen all the time... I'm advocating for making a sta...

Renji, Please read my last post again... What you're saying has nothing to do with to do with what I'm saying.

The point is... The instances mentioned above DO happen anyway and a judgement then needs to be made when they do... This is regarding those judgments...

So... this reply is intended to be Read by anyone who can possibly help make a change. I will try to be as clear as I can for the time being. Renji, You say the person not replying is at fault but the person who is asking, what if he only waits 3 seconds? I’m pretty sure the judge will rule in the p...

I agree with you Genexwrecker but there's a lot of confusion on what is considered "ok" from the opponent as this is not IRL. I just think that we can all benefit if there is a consensus on what is considered as "ok" from the opponent, if they decide not to reply. Or maybe you ca...

Just edited the 2nd reply after your feedback. Thanks again